Showing posts with label LETTERS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LETTERS. Show all posts

Sunday, May 28, 2017

Memorial Day: 'Your Dear Son is Dead'

Union private Oliver Stebbins
 The Civil War was nearly over when John and Charlotte Stebbins of Three Rivers, Michigan, sent their oldest son Oliver to join the Union Army.
 He enlisted Feb. 17, 1865, in the 11th Michigan Cavalry, which was one of the eight brigades assigned to Stoneman's Raid. They rode out of Knoxville, Tennessee, on March 21, 1865—Oliver's 18th birthday.
 For the next four weeks, Stoneman's troops were beyond the reach of mail or telegraph, so we can assume that Stebbins' family heard nothing from him. They must have rejoiced to hear of the fall of Richmond April 2 and the surrender of Gen. Robert E. Lee April 9—certain signs that the war was ending and that their son would soon be coming home.
 Then came the following heartbreaking letters, the first two from a fellow Michigan soldier named John Schroder. [The crude spelling and wording is preserved from the original letters. I have inserted a few explanatory notes in brackets.]

Chattanooga, Tenn. April the 23 1865

Mrs. Stebbins,
I will let you know about your Oliver he is sick in the Hospital here. he was brought here with the Measles he has got over the Measles and has got Nuemonia in his side and the Bronchetis in the other side it is a hard case I have been here sick with the Measles and am just getting over them I am doing all that I can for your Dear Son he is very thirsty and wants watter every little while I watched him all last night and if he was in his right mind I assure you he will get well my bed is right beside his if he wants any thing he cals on me but I dont know whether he is in his right mind or not I see that he has something to eat every meal for I giv it to him myself I belong to the same regiment that he does. I will write you again in two or three days No more at present
John Schroder Co J 11th Michigan Inf Chattanooga, Tennessee

Monday, October 17, 2016

Greenville: 'Prepare to Meet Your God'

A noble Yankee from Tennessee:
Union Capt. Isaac Taylor
 
GREENVILLE, S.C.
 The Stoneman Gazette has unearthed more information about the skirmish in Greenville, S.C., in May, 1865, that I believe was the last Civil War clash east of the Mississippi.
National Tribune, Sept. 5, 1889
 This clipping was published July 18, 1889, in the National Tribune, a weekly newspaper catering to Union veterans. I found it reprinted Sept. 5, 1889, in the Anderson Intelligencer.
 It is a letter written by Isaac Taylor, a Union captain from Tennessee who was ordered to execute four Confederates accused of mistreating and robbing some of Stoneman's sick and wounded soldiers as they were being evacuated to Knoxville.
 Convinced that the rebels were innocent, Capt. Taylor defied his orders and made a noble last-minute decision to spare their lives.
 I believe that Taylor is describing the same incident that was documented in 2002 by Greenville historian John McLeod, though there are some discrepancies in their stories, and it is possible there were two similar incidents.
 Taylor gives the date as May 24 (rather than May 22 or 23) and the location as 25 miles from Greenville at the foot of the Blue Ridge (not Crescent Ridge near downtown Greenville). He says there were four Confederates (rather than three) facing the firing squad. The 1903 history of the 13th Tennessee Cavalry says it was Lt. T.C. White (rather than Capt. Taylor) who was ordered to carry out the executions.
 Capt. Taylor vividly described the scene as the rebels awaited their fate:
They were informed of the order and given 10 minutes in which to prepare to meet their God. I had passed through many battles and trials, but this was the most trying ordeal of my life. The utter despair depicted on their countenances, while great rivers of perspiration ran down their pallid faces, makes me shudder yet when I think of how near four innocent men were to being murdered by the command "fire" given from my lips.
 Then the surgeon (Dr. James Cameron) recognized a gesture from one of the rebels as the Masons' "Grand-Hailing Sign of Distress." Dr. Cameron was a Mason, and so was Col. Miller, the brigade commander who had ordered the executions.  This made Miller reconsider the charges, and he set the captives free.
 The Civil War is full of stories like this where lives were spared after enemies discovered they were brothers in the secret society of the Masons. In fact, there is a Masonic Memorial at Gettysburg called "Friend to Friend" (pictured below) that honors these traditions. Several similar accounts are found in the annals of Stoneman's Raid. No doubt some are apocryphal, but I think this one is credible, since it is reported by both sides. 
Emporia (Kan.) News, Jan. 24, 1884

 Capt. Taylor (1843-1892) grew up in eastern Tennessee, which was predominantly pro-Union and opposed to secession. When the war began, he enlisted with an Illinois regiment. In 1863 he joined the Union's 13th Tennessee Cavalry, commanding Company B and serving as Acting Assistant Adjutant General under Col. John Miller. The 13th Tennessee was one of eight Yankee regiments that marched with Stoneman's Raid in the spring of 1865. They fought at Wytheville and the Yadkin River bridge and were involved in the pursuit of Jefferson Davis.
 According to this 1884 newspaper tribute, he was the first man in Carter County, Tennessee, to make a stand for Negro suffrage, and he was among the first Republicans elected to the Tennessee legislature. 
 Republicans fell out of favor at the end of Reconstruction, so Capt. Taylor moved to Hartford, Kan., where he built a mill, became president of the local bank, and served as an Indian agent.
 He wrote to the National Tribune in 1889 hoping to make contact with his forgiven enemies:
I disobeyed orders, turned them over to the brigade commander at noon with a full statement of what had occurred, and he discharged them. They were happy, but I cannot believe that they were more so than I was. A Masonic sign saved their lives, and no doubt, saved me from great remorse. If those four ex-Confederates, or any of them, are living, I would be very happy indeed to hear from them.
 Earlier in 1889, Taylor had written to the National Tribune in another attempt to reconcile with the enemy. He said he was seeking to find the rightful owner of a Virginia regimental banner "he captured from the rebels in South Carolina in the spring of 1865." The 13th Tennessee passed through the northwest corner of South Carolina twice during Stoneman's Raid, but I am not aware of any fights they had there with Virginians.
 Taylor died three years later at age 49, and I don't know if he ever heard from any of those rebels. Although he was not familiar with Masonic rites during the war, he evidently apprenticed later, because his obituary says his funeral was conducted by the Knights Templar with Masonic honors.
 According to a biographical sketch in the History of the 13th Regiment, Tennessee Volunteer Cavalry
Captain Taylor was an officer of the highest courage, never evading any duty or danger, but was always among the first to reach the danger line when there was fighting to be done. He possessed fine social qualities and a high sense of honor that endeared him to all who knew him.
The Masonic Memorial at Gettysburg portrays Union Capt. Henry Bingham
comforting Confederate Gen. Lewis Armistead, who was
 mortally wounded during Pickett's Charge.
 
 

The fallen Gen. Armistead is portrayed in this Gettysburg scene, painted by James Walker and displayed in the Johnson Collection at the Spartanburg County Library in S.C. 


New York Times, Feb. 20, 1870



Wednesday, May 6, 2015

Reason for the war? How quickly they forgot

William Palmer as a young Union colonel

 Some of us still debate whether the Civil War was about slavery. If a pollster had asked Stoneman's raiders why they were fighting, I doubt that many of them would have cited an emancipation provocation. Even some who condemned slavery as an institution displayed little concern for the welfare of the freedmen
 But in the eyes of Union Gen. William Jackson Palmer, slavery was the one and only reason for the war. As a Quaker, Palmer was morally opposed to fighting, but he was even more passionately opposed to slavery. In his heart, emancipation was a cause worth fighting for.
 Before the war, Palmer been involved in abolitionist rallies. Afterwards, he became a major supporter of Hampton Institute to educate the children of freed slaves.
 After fighting for four years to free the slaves (and earning the Medal of Honor along the way), Palmer was appalled to hear reports that the new president, Andrew Johnson of Tennessee, might "phase in" emancipation, delaying the end of slavery in order to help heal the wounds of secession. Even while he was commanding the last days of Stoneman's Raid and leading the pursuit of Jefferson Davis in Georgia, Palmer took time to write this eloquent letter to an influential friend in Philadelphia, urging President Johnson to never compromise on the abolition of slavery.
 Samuel C. Morton was a longtime president of the Philadelphia Board of Trade:


ATHENS, Ga.
 May 6, 1865
Mr. Samuel C. Morton
Philadelphia, Penna.
Dear Sir,
     I have no right to communicate directly with the President of the United States, being forbidden by the position I hold in the army, but as I have had peculiar and extraordinary opportunities of becoming acquainted with the phases of public sentiment among the most intelligent men of North and South Carolina and Georgia since the surrender of Lee’s army, I have a strong desire that President Johnson should become acquainted with one or two points that I shall mention in this letter.
     Of course, everybody has abandoned the cause, and the most intelligent and influential men everywhere have candidly acknowledged to me that they are entirely in the power of the United States Government, and will have to submit to any terms that may be imposed. Not one of them has the slightest expectation of any continued resistance in the Trans-Mississippi Department—nor do they wish it. I am satisfied from the inquiries made of me by leading men in all three States, that a strong united effort will be made throughout the South to influence Northern sentiment to grant the gradual abolition of slavery. This is the utmost they hope for.
     Now I hope most sincerely that those who have the settlement of this matter will not be influenced (by any fear of a sullen resistance to the authority of the Government or any desire to pacify the Southern people and make them give a cheerful submission to what is so unpalatable) to yield this point. They should consent to nothing but an immediate and unconditional abolition of slavery. I have told these people everywhere that no matter what else is done, this is inevitable; that as they evidently expected universal confiscation, subjugation, and in some case annihilation, they should deem the other mild terms; that as their labor system has to be reorganized on a compensatory basis, the soon it is begun the sooner they will have a stable system—and that they have more to fear from insurrection and disturbances among the negroes if their emancipation is procrastinated than if it were immediate, especially since the whites have been disarmed and so many of the blacks made soldiers.
     Some of their leading people have partially admitted the force of these arguments, but all would, I am convinced, cheerfully submit to these terms if they found that this was the best and the worst, and that no general confiscation would ensue.
     If slavery is not immediately got rid of, pacification will be indefinitely delayed, and political parties in the North will before long be based on this issue.
     I would be glad to see even the leaders of the rebellion or most of them pardoned, and not a dollar’s worth of other than slave property confiscated, in order to gain this point, and it might be done in a way to ensure the influence of these leaders to make the main point (immediate abolition) palatable to the Southern people.
     The crime of rebellion is so great that any punishment of these concerned seems trifling and insignificant. And the value of the property that might be confiscated to the United States Government is absurdly small compared to the mere pecuniary advantages it would derive from the increase of taxable property in the South, in a very few years under a free labor system.
     But let us have freedom everywhere—the whites of the South expect it, the negroes are longing for it, and civilization and peace demand it.
                With kind regards to yourself, I am, Sir,
                Yours very respectfully,
                WM. J. PALMER
                Brev. Brig. Genl.
                (Commanding Stoneman’s Cavalry)

Rebels explain why they seceded

 So was the Civil War really about slavery? Or states' rights? Or northern aggression?
 After 150 years of spin, we all have our opinions.
 I suggest we all take a deep breath and listen to the statements of those who voted to leave the Union. Six of the 11 states expressly mentioned slavery either in their ordinances of secession or in the supporting declarations of cause.
 For example, this is what Mississippi said in its Declaration of Cause:
In the momentous step which our State has taken of dissolving its connection with the government of which we so long formed a part, it is but just that we should declare the prominent reasons which have induced our course.
Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery—the greatest material interest of the world. Its labor supplies the product which constitutes by far the largest and most important portions of commerce of the earth. These products are peculiar to the climate verging on the tropical regions, and by an imperious law of nature, none but the black race can bear exposure to the tropical sun. These products have become necessities of the world, and a blow at slavery is a blow at commerce and civilization. That blow has been long aimed at the institution, and was at the point of reaching its consummation. There was no choice left us but submission to the mandates of abolition, or a dissolution of the Union, whose principles had been subverted to work out our ruin.
 Texas went even further, declaring that the government was established by and for the white race (implicitly affirming the 1857 Dred Scott decision):
We hold as undeniable truths that the governments of the various States, and of the confederacy itself, were established exclusively by the white race, for themselves and their posterity; that the African race had no agency in their establishment; that they were rightfully held and regarded as an inferior and dependent race, and in that condition only could their existence in this country be rendered beneficial or tolerable.
 This is not to say that there were not noble reasons for Southerners to fight, especially when their homelands were invaded by hordes of Yankees. Most rebels did not own slaves. Most of them probably would not have voted to secede. (North Carolina actually held a referendum, and the voters rejected secession.)
 But their leaders did, and did.
 Read their words, and then tell me what you think. 


Sunday, May 3, 2015

Emmala's War: 'Perhaps we deserved it'

Last of three episodes

This eyewitness account of Stoneman's Raid in Anderson May 1-3, 1865 is reprinted with permission from "A Faithful Heart: The Journals of Emmala Reed, 1865 and 1866," edited by Robert Oliver and published in 2004 by USC Press. Click here to start on May 1 or to buy the book.

 Wednesday, May 3, 1865
  
ANDERSON, S.C.
Emmala Reed Miller
 Wednesday, May 3 was a calm, lovely day—for a while no tramping, cursing foes, no rattling of vehicles & of citizens, but all resting from the excitement & robbed of their treasures. Yet, ere night it was waxed higher than ever for 'twas said that Kirk's raiders, or outlaws from the mountains, were coming down to burn & destroy. Some thought that Sherman's or Thomas' armies were next. Many wild rumors afloat—so we all picked up clothes to move out in case of burning and hid bundles at obscure houses, &c.
 Our negroes went out to camp & brought in sacks of corn. Many bushels were gathered by the people & other valuables. We had thought that several of the men had gone or wished to go off, but all were faithful. Yet some confessed that it was because they were too old and had families they couldn’t leave behind. Some talked a little pert, were idle & free a few days, but all soon settled down to their usual routine. Very respectful as far as we can see, but I rather dread them. 
 We heard such bad reports from Grandpa’s that Tom Carter had to leave us in the evening & go to them. We missed him much—were alone that awful night—for we heard wilder rumors than ever. All the men in town nearly hid out in the woods for being "hurt" as was threatened. Pa was persuaded to go—as a prominent "Secesh" with many home enemies too. He with Dr. Broyles & several Charleston men stole out at dark and remained safe in the woods all night.
 In the afternoon a parcel of the provost guard & other rash boys were here. [The provost guard was essentially a self-appointed police force.] Came to Pa to get arms to go out & arrest some stragglers, but he persuaded them not to do so—it would do only harm. (It was reported afterwards that he encouraged it & was marked for it—we trembled for that!) But they would go their way, & a small squad arrested two Yankees. A small party came up. Some threats & shots exchanged in town. One youth was shot dead or left to die there, alone in the streets, whilst all scattered. "Theodore Parker” of Charleston. Nephew of the Perroneaus here—a boy of 17—very rash, but brave.
 Dick Tupper was knocked in the breast by a gun—almost fainted, revived in the hotel. He & Joe Hyde pursued home by pistols several times. A negro man shot accidentally, his leg was amputated and he died, probably from too much chloroform. So that was the sad tragedy of the war in our streets.
 We feared they would take vengeance that night, but thank heaven we were spared. 
 About midnight heard many troops march through. Palmer’s Com’d perhaps, & a negro Brigade. All went through quietly several nights—in perfect control, with flags of truce—disturbing no one. They went on through to Georgia, where they were garrisoned at Athens & different towns, we hear—for they consider the whole South subjugated, & it virtually is.
 We can make no further resistance, but what is to be our fate? The order was promulgated that Sherman & Grant were making terms of peace, & hostilities were to cease, but we don’t know the particulars. Only hope that old Andy Johnson won’t be allowed control, for he will give no mercy, we hear. Rumors of foreign aid & recognition keep coming, but we don’t know the truth. There are no mails, we have no money, no means, no gov’t, no hope scarcely! Are a ruined, humiliated people! Awful to contemplate.
 Perhaps we deserved it for sin & imbecility—a falling off from just principles. The civil & military authorities corrupt, desertion, speculation, robbery, drinking, mismanagement, and the loss of confidence in the Pres’t & civil authorities—ruined us—whilst a powerful, persevering, cunning, cruel Yankee nation have outnumbered us & overpowered us, but what will the end be we fear to know. All feel subdued but bear our calamities as cheerfully as possible.

Saturday, May 2, 2015

Greenville: 'Raid is the worst form of war'

Yankees camped May 2, 1865, around Furman's 'Old Main,' whose bell used to ring out the news of Confederate victories. When the university relocated in the 1950s, the iconic bell tower was duplicated on the new campus.
GREENVILLE, S.C.
 Throughout the four years of the Civil War, Greenville remained a safe haven.
 Three weeks after Lee's surrender, on May 1, 1865, a potential cavalry showdown was avoided when hundreds of unsurrendered rebels under Gen. Joseph Wheeler camped in the town while Stoneman's Union troops passed through the countryside a few miles to the south as they headed toward Anderson.
 But Greenville's troubles weren't over. Townfolk barely had time to breathe a sigh of relief before more Union troops under Stoneman's command came charging down Rutherford Road. This time, there would be suffering and bloodshed. 
Caroline Gilman
(portrait by John Wesley Jarvis)
 The scene on May 2 was described in a letter by Caroline Howard Gilman, 71, a noted poet who had moved from Charleston to Greenville following the death of her husband, who was a Unitarian minister for 40 years. Gilman's family was sitting down for a barbecue 150 years ago to celebrate the end of the war:
     A sense of calm, if not happiness, was shed over us by the thought that our friends were not in mortal combat and had full confidence that the flag of truce would be respected.
     It seems to me that a Raid is the worst form of war, for its professed object is to attack the defenseless, to pillage women and children, and destroy their homes. What was our horror then to hear a cry from the servants, “The Yankees are coming!’
     Presently, a negro man in a cart, whipping his horse to a full gallop, came tearing along to escape, but in vain. A dozen of the enemy’s cavalry came after him and fired. In an instant, almost, his horse was unharnessed and taken possession of.
     Clusters of horsemen passed and looked and rode on without a question, while in other houses they were searching for arms and horses.
     One man came on foot, while I was leaning over the porch rails, and demanded coffee. I said I had been without coffee for two months. "I hear you have coffee," he said, "and if I find it is so, I’ll be damned if I don’t burn your house down."
     The Raiders, about two hundred in number, went to Main Street and opened the Commissary stores, robbed the Bank, pillaged every article of clothing from the rooms of the Ladies' Association, and then proceeded to private houses and property. [The Ladies' Association cared for wounded soldiers.]
     Everything was rifled. Books, costly plates, wines, pictures, bed linens thrown into the street to be picked up by any passerby. All the afternoon we saw white and black laden with goods, passing by the house.
 The raiders in Greenville were part of Stoneman's rear guard who had tormented Boone, N.C., for two weeks and had been repositioned in Asheville. Union Gen. Davis Tillson dispatched 150 mounted infantry under Major James Lawson to join the pursuit of Jefferson Davis and perhaps claim the $100,000 bounty on the fugitive Confederate president.
 Lawson's men quickly realized they had a better chance of cashing in from the unplundered homes and businesses of Greenville, which was a summer home for several Charleston families. In the basement of Hamlin Beattie's store on Main Street, they uncovered a hollow spot behind a brick wall and pulled out $30,000 in gold belonging to the Bank of Charleston.
 During the raid, according to Col. Alston Deas, Mrs. Gilman personally rescued a priceless set of portraits of the Rutledge and Pinckney families from Charleston. 
 Maj. Lawson's troops camped the night of May 2 on the original campus of Furman University, which had been closed because of the war. They plundered the home of Rev. James Petigru Boyce, the founder of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary (which opened in 1859 at Furman University and reopened in 1877 in Louisville, Ky). They demanded his diamonds and silver, and he calmly defied them even when they held a pistol to his head.
Josiah Choice was buried in
Greenville's Springwood Cemetery
 At least two Greenville men were killed during the raid, according to historians. Capt. Josiah Choice, 62, of the Old Rock House on Buncombe Road, was shot for one of two reasons—either he wounded a Federal soldier or  threatened to kill anyone who took his horse (according to books by James Richardson and Robert Seigler). An unidentified former slave was hunted down and killed by Lawson's troops "for impudence;" he was suspected of shooting at an armory worker the previous day. Click here to read more about these incidents. 
 Maj. Lawson is a mystery to me. I haven't been able to identify him in the 2nd N.C. Mounted Infantry under Gen. Tillson. There were several James Lawsons in the Union Army from Kentucky and Illinois, but none of them are listed as officers. 
Greenville authorities decided wisely not to make a stand against the Union cavalry. Richardson wrote:
Recognizing the futility of resistance, the residents of Greenville obeyed orders to give up their weapons and deliver provisions to the Union troops. Greenville’s compliance allowed the town to escape the destruction many other Southern towns endured; however, warehouses in the town were looted and many valuables were destroyed.
The Arsenal Cadets from Columbia had been guarding the armory in Greenville, but they prudently retreated when they learned that two of Stoneman's brigades were headed that way on April 30. The next day near Williamston, they were involved in a skirmish with some of Stoneman's cavalry.
Six weeks after Lee's surrender, Greenville had another brush with Stoneman's raiders, resulting in a long-forgotten incident that was the last Civil War skirmish east of the Mississippi. 

A near miss with Stoneman's captors

      The rebels in Greenville May 1 were from Gen. Joseph Wheeler's cavalry—the same troops who captured Stoneman nine months earlier in Georgia, making him the highest ranking prisoner the Confederacy ever held. (Some of Stoneman's men repaid that debt on May 10 in Georgia, when they captured Wheeler not far from where Wheeler's troops had cornered Stoneman.)
      Wheeler's men had refused to surrender April 18 along with the rest of the Confederate forces in the Carolinas. Instead, they escorted President Jefferson Davis through North Carolina. On April 29 in Charlotte, Wheeler dismissed them to go home to Georgia and Tennessee, which is where they were headed from Greenville. His farewell words:
Gallant Comrades:
     You have fought your battles; your task is done. During a four-year struggle for liberty, you have exhibited courage, fortitude and devotion; you are the sole victors of more than two hundred severely contested fields; you have participated in more than a thousand successful conflicts of arms. You are heroes, veterans, patriots. The bones of your comrades mark battlefields upon the soil of Kentucky, Tennessee, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama and Mississippi; you have done all that human exertion could accomplish. In bidding you adieu, I desire to tender my thanks for your gallantry in battle, your fortitude under suffering, and your devotion at all times to the holy cause you have done so much to maintain. I desire also to express my gratitude for the kind feeling you have seen fit to extend toward myself, and to invoke upon you the blessings of our heavenly Father, to whom we must always look for support in the hour of distress. Brethren in the cause of freedom, comrades in arms, I bid you farewell.
J. WHEELER 


Emmala's War: Many drunken demons

Emmala Reed lived at Echo Hall, which was between Main Street and McDuffie Street south of downtown. She wrote that one of the Yankees "shivered a sword" on this gate and took a chunk out of it.

Second of three episodes

This eyewitness account of Stoneman's Raid in Anderson May 1-3, 1865 is reprinted with permission from "A Faithful Heart: The Journals of Emmala Reed, 1865 and 1866," edited by Robert Oliver and published in 2004 by USC Press. Click here to start on May 1 or to buy the book.

Tuesday, May 2, 1865


Emmala Reed Miller
     Tuesday, May 2nd dawned at last. A long day of terror. All up & watchful with the early dawn. Three ladies came early to ask Pa to help them get a guard. 
     The Broyles had been searched—horses, arms, the vegetables in the garden taken and their father’s watch. [Dr. Broyles was the father of Emmala's beloved "Robere."] The faithful old timepiece, by which he had connoted pulses—30 years—snatched from him—to the regret of all.
      Gus (Broyles) & Tiny Bacon fled from the Enrolling officer in Greenville and that day had just entered the house and been thus surprised. Robert & Tom and John, the three youngest brothers, just from the Army. The two just paroled from Lee’s army & could have stayed at home safely, but all were taken by surprise. Thought it was Kirk’s desperate raiders & so all started at the first alarm and rushed to the woods and swamps for safety.
     The Williams mounted their fine horses & leaping the fence, were gone like a flash and escaped all. John and Gus—too late to mount—horses taken—ran off on foot one way, but were captured next day and paroled, though they threatened to take Capt. Gus to Tenn. He & all the Enrolling office here escaped after much pleading. Robere & Col. Edward B ran toward their farm on Rocky River—pursued and shot at, but escaped throughout by lying in swamps several days. (Manuell feeding them.) And all that time I had no token from him—only my fears & suspense. What did it mean?
     We all sat talking the day away in anxious suspense—a long, bright, sunny day. Stragglers would come around—with evil intentions, no doubt, but were repelled by the guard. Our Lt. took every meal with us—talking much. Meanwhile, the ruffians were let loose & were throwing open the stores, public & private, in town—pillaging everything, assisted by poor whites & negroes who made themselves rich for once. Quantities of cloth & thread and a variety of articles, fancy and useful. Bacon, flour—salt & sugar were cast away.
     All our negroes & everybody’s were there, taking off loads. Some shared with their owners. We got some fine thread & writing paper only. They all roamed about free & careless for several days & no work done. They no doubt thought the year of Jubilee had come. All dreamed of freedom & discussed the prospect, no doubt, but were too sensible to go off with this wild raiding party, save the reckless boys—who dashed around on horses. Proudly and defiantly! Dozens went off from here, but many were sent back or willingly returned to good homes and owners and get on now as usual. We thought some of ours might go, but didn’t care much. Let them choose their own fate. May it be for the best!
     The wild crew tore up everything in the depot—cars & railroad—fruit &c. Then on to the University—the Treasury Dp’t now, which no doubt attracted them here. We could hear the destruction all morning, as all the iron presses & works were broken to pieces & confederate paper money scattered all over the earth—books &c burned up. All totally demolished!  Much of the money was not signed and valueless. So it all will be soon. Every negro & child had piles of it. Hundreds of dollars which we took as worthless, but 'tis so useless and so humiliating now to think that this is the fate of our currency and our Gov’t!
     All of our old school relics were destroyed up there, except Mrs. Daniel’s tablet—safe here. 
     So the work of destruction went on all day. Many houses were entered and plundered of clothes—silver, jewels, provisions & everything, but it was because the wretches had broken into the stores of liquors which we should have poured out.  Many drunken demons did fearful damage—with oaths & insults to many poor creatures without guards. We feared our town would be destroyed by the drunken mad-men as was Columbia, but thank heaven—'twas spared!
     The Tuppers lost everything & suffered much. The Silcoxes were plundered and alarmed—poor Tillie sick & fainting. The old man hidden out & half crazy. Mr. Myers, who suffered so much in Columbia, had spasms since, and was hung up until nearly dead, to make him reveal about their gold—failed. Dr. Cater’s place and clothes torn up. He hung up for the same purpose. So at the Winthrops: Dr. W was hung up & beaten with a shovel. Even good old Mrs. W threatened with hanging. The Ruccors’ house, being empty, was sacked—furniture and & destroyed. Whitener’s house threatened with burning, Mrs. Glover & other ladies made to play the piano for them.
     Elias Earle’s family suffered most perhaps—pointed out as rich. Palmer’s brigade—coming from Greenville—had camped there. He & staff in the house, but protected nothing. Destroyed all the provisions & clothes. Took negroes & made them give up jewels and silver & gold. Shot at the ladies & made them produce the buried treasure or would burn. Started to hang up poor Preston, but all stood out bravely. Said burn or hang, I won’t yield.
     On the whole, no lives were lost, & everyone can manage to live, I guess. Many horses were taken, but they left mean ones behind and gave to other people. So some crops can be made, perhaps. A fearful prospect still, but thank heavens it was no worse.
     At noon, our Yankee Lt. came & brought some of the fine wines and brandy as a present to Clif &c, to my regret, for he and Tom loved to drink it too well. 'Twas old and very fine, & may serve us in sickness yet. 
     Then we heard their band of music playing in the courthouse finely. Many stirring airs, which we couldn’t help admiring. It broke sweetly on the calm, sunny air of noon—filled with bloom and fragrance, but I wept sadly. Our Lt. promised to bring the band to serenade us, but did not fortunately or it might have been spoken of.
     At last that weary day had dragged over & brought another long sleepless night. Our Lt. had talked much & asked me to play and sing, which I didn’t like to do—but did. Sang a few tame songs. Didn’t care to attempt any national air & provoke words. He said nothing—asked Eleanor for Dixie.
     Suddenly about 10 o’clock there was a bugle call to mount. They started up in surprise & wouldn’t tell what it meant—settled down to stay anyway, as we hoped, for we feared it was a signal to burn or something, but it wasn’t repeated. They were sent for by a young bugler—who ate supper & then they went—saying they expected to march on but wouldn’t say why or where they were in such hot haste. Gave hints that it was in pursuit of Pres’t Davis, as we heard he was passing through with many guards to the Trans-Mississippi, & we hoped they will escape.
     Our Lt. rode off in haste, saying "my love to you all!" & he would return if they stayed. Our guard lingered around for some time, willing to stay and protect us, but he too mounted his tall Rosinante & rode off with some rations for our thanks. We listened then to the different bugle calls & orders to mount! Forward! March, &c, whilst their band played “Yankee Doodle.”
     We heard the dull, heavy tramp of retreating thousands at the hour of midnight, until all was silent. We knew not their object and trembled for the result, thinking that they had left orders to burn the public works. There were many threats made about Pa’s & Col. Orr’s houses, & we trembled. 
     All night long we watched in suspense, hearing still the dashing of patrols I suppose, but many houses were robbed & threatened. We just escaped several times—thank heaven! At least that weary night was over!

NEXT➤ Greenville: 'Raid is the worst form of war' 
EMMALA'S WAR, Chapter 3➤ 'A ruined, humiliated people'

Friday, May 1, 2015

How to stop the U.S. Cavalry? With a winefest

The southeast side of the Anderson square shortly after the war. B.F. Crayton's store is on the far right. 
ANDERSON, S.C.
     Let's play the Stoneman's Raid version of "Let's Make A Deal."
     You look like a fine bunch of Union cavalrymen. You can have fame, fortune, and everlasting thanks of your country if you will ride just 30 more miles to Abbeville, capture Jefferson Davis, and end the Civil War.
     Or would you rather have what's behind B.F. Crayton's cellar door?
     The Yankees in Anderson 150 years ago chose the latter. Gen. Simeon Brown had a clue of what was hidden down there, but his larcenous troops would have found it anyway. The musty half-basement of the Crayton Store on the courthouse square in Anderson held a treasure twice as valuable as the bounty of gold on Jeff Davis' head.
     Liquid assets, you might say. Rare wines and an exotic array of liquors.
     There were hundreds and hundreds of bottles of fine Madeira and port wines, bottled on islands off the coast of Portugal. You had to be part of the Kingdom of Charleston to appreciate or afford them. Blockade runners risked their lives to deliver the stuff across the Atlantic.
     But what in the devil were all his tempting concoctions doing in Anderson?
     Blame Sherman, of course.
     Union Gen. William Tecumseh Sherman had completed his march across Georgia, and on Christmas Day of 1864 he presented Savannah as a Christmas gift to President Lincoln. Charlestonians naturally feared they would his next target. (They were so vain, they probably thought this war was about them.) Sherman surprised Charleston by going to Columbia instead, which is why the Confederate money-printing operations were suddenly relocated from Columbia to Anderson at the end of the war. 
     For safekeeping, a Charleston wine merchant named Guardine (or Gourdin) decided to move his storehouse as far from Charleston as the railroads would go. Anderson was about the end of the line, except for an unfinished spur that dead-ended in Stumphouse Tunnel near Walhalla. The bottles and barrels probably filled most of a boxcar. Depending on whose account you trust, there may have been more than 3,000 bottles worth close to $200,000.
     The bounty on Jeff Davis was a measly $100,000. 
     (Wine was so profitable that an 18th-century Charleston wine merchant named Henri Peronneau became known as the richest man in colonial America. One of his heirs was the only Andersonian killed in Stoneman's Raid and probably the next-to-last Confederate to die in the Civil War.)
     Anderson Judge J.P. Reed actually told Union Gen. Simeon Brown about the wine cellar late in the afternoon of May 1, 1865. Judge Reed was trying to save the town, and he thought alcohol might mellow and pacify the 1,900 troops (representing Stoneman's 2nd and 3rd Brigades) until they moved on.
     His daughter Emmala Reed wasn't so sure. She recorded in her journal:
Pa pointed out to him a building where were stored quantities of liquours of Mr. Guardine of Charleston—wine merchant. At least $200,000 worth of splendid old wines—brandies &c considered invaluable by these men, but ought to have been destroyed—to prevent drunkenness and ruin here which was visited upon Columbia. He [Gen. Brown] promised to keep his soldiers from it, but didn’t try. They were soon breaking in and drinking madly, and all trembled for the effects.
     There was still plenty of wine left the following evening when Stoneman's 1st Brigade with 2,000 cavalrymen reached Anderson. Pennsylvania Capt. Henry Weand wrote in his journal: 
Nearly all our men had a canteen full, and barrels of it were emptied into the gutters of the streets by standing orders from General Stoneman, who was fearful of its demoralizing effects on his troops. When Gen. Gillem’s troops reached North Carolina a short time ago [March 30 in Wilkes County, N.C.], they ran across a distillery from which they took enough apple whiskey to intoxicate the whole force, and Stoneman wanted no more of it.
     It's debatable whether Judge Reed's ploy worked. As far as I know, no homes or businesses were burned in Anderson, and no residents were killed by the stoned men who occupied Anderson May 1-2. Sadly, that would soon change at the hands of another Union cavalry outfit.
     On the other hand, many Andersonians had their homes looted by men they described as "drunken wretches" or "drunken demons." The two brigades that initially occupied Anderson were notorious for their lack of discipline, and unlimited alcohol would have only made things worse.
     One thing is for sure: The Union cavalry was bogged down May 2 in Anderson, while Jefferson Davis was just 30 miles away in Abbeville holding the last war council of the Rebellion. Davis got away from Stoneman's Raid, and ultimately so did the bounty.

Emmala's War: Audacity of 'the cute Yankee'

First of three episodes
 
     Emmala Reed was the daughter of Anderson judge J.P. Reed and lived in one of the town's finest homes, Echo Hall, on South Main Street. She was in love with a Confederate surgeon who was away fighting the war. Then her "Robere" came home and broke her heart by marrying another.
     Her unrequited love is the theme of "A Faithful Heart: The Journals of Emmala Reed, 1865 and 1866." Robert Oliver, who edited her journals, has graciously given us permission to publish her entries for May 1-3, 1865, when Stoneman's Raid was in Anderson.
     Unlike "Emma's War" (the serial we presented two weeks ago from the Carson House in Marion, N.C.), this is not a composed memoir but instead is a real-time eyewitness report. You are reading a diary, not an essay. I've edited it lightly for readability, trimmed a few extraneous passages, and added explanatory words in brackets. Otherwide, I've tried to preserve her style, right down to the &c she used for etc.
     Emmala Reed Miller (1839-1893) eventually became a teacher near Columbia, where she married George Miller and raised six children. If you'd like to know more about her, start with this 2011 story by Jennifer Crossley Howard in my old newspaper, the Independent-Mail.
     If you enjoy this peek into her diary, why not buy the book?

Emmala Reed's diary, displayed at the Anderson County Museum

Monday, May 1, 1865


     Monday, May 1, 1865, dawned as bright and beautiful as every Mayday before—but we little expected it to be so desecrated here. All schools & young folks of the village went out on picnics in the woods—with lunch and dances and funmany of our village soldiers at home & some strangers. I was not invited to any—strange. Eleanor & Helen went to one—Mamie to another and thus they were all scattered—when the enemy approached and flew home amongst them in the greatest alarm.
     Rumors of their approach came all day. Pa came at noon said it was positive—advized us to pack up our clothes & valuables for moving off in the country somewhere that night, though we could think of no place of safety. We went to the plantation to order the mules & wagons to be brought up quietly, thinking we were a day ahead. Ma began to tear up drawers to pack clothes and silver &c in boxes, but I hadn’t the energy or heart to do anything. Felt petrified & despairing.
     My greatest grief being that I could not see Robere & perhaps might never again, until some awful changes had swept over one or both. Destruction of property, of persons, or change of heart that might alter our whole after life, but I never thought we could forget or neglect each other! Then we hurried around wildly, but in a few minutes more they were upon us, and all was wild terror & confusion!
     I had just torn my clothes out of my trunk &c when many horsemen galloped by—shouting & shooting. And for a moment I did not dream it was the foe, but then it came—"the Yankees, the Yankees!" And all of us rushed together screaming, Ma & the children—white & black—and we girls—negroes all willing to help us bring & hide clothes and silver &c—some of them crying in terror.
     We found they were pursuing some southern cavalry passing through & taking up all the men prisoners—paroling some—passing by those who had paroles from Lee’s army, but confining many in the courthouse for a few days. Clifton was so excited & rash—rushed out toward those who were rushing madly past exclaiming "what does this mean?" &c.
The front gate at Echo Hall, where Emmala said one Yankee "shivered a sword."

     Several stopped at the gate—calling him to come out with many oaths or they would blow his brains out—with arms pointed towards him and one shivered a sword on the gate, of which I have a scrap. They made he & Tom Carter walk before them, to town, as prisoners. They observed Tom’s parole, but Clif had some problem in getting them to "respect his stump," but at last an officer let him come home. They hurried back to our delight, for we were all in terror here. [Emmala's brother, Clifton Augustus Reed (1845-1924) had lost his right hand in a battlefield injury.]
     Then three great ruffians in blue suits and fully armed rushed in the back way to Ma’s room—calling for arms—took an old gun & shivered it. "Knew we had more"—we had just hidden two & saved them, but we had to get out three elegant little pistols & give them up. Yet the key to the drawer could scarcely be found. Ma was excited but talked cool—tried in vain to find the key awhile, they impatient—threatening to break I open, but at last they got them & marched off. One had primped himself before the glass. So cool & impudent.
     I felt so humiliated & alarmed, but calm. Then a crowd came in the other way and called for liquor—had to get a jug full, which they got & dashed off with. We feared much danger from these drunken wretches. But all these were in terror of being detected by officers—we could see—for they were so hurried. And just then an elegant looking young officer—Captain [W.J.] Patterson—Adj. Gen’l of Brown’s Division—Stoneman’s corps—came & rang the bell politely. He asked if we could have a guard—sorry it had not come before we were molested &c. In a few moments sent one who proved a most faithful & invaluable sentinel & saved us much danger.
     But ere this—a gang had taken both of our good old carriage horses from the stable—"Pearce and Derry"—ordering Emory [a Reed family servant] to give them up. We were too sorry to see them going off—rode through our yard afterwards. What will be their fate? To be rode to death very soon, I’ve no doubt. How we shall miss them—no more riding for us!
     Pa advanced to meet the Gen’ls Brown & Miller of Stoneman’s cavalry raid of over 2,000 men—who had at last come to sweep our little unprotected village! They had been trying to get up some defense before, but 'twas well that none was attempted or we would have been destroyed! We hear they said "They hoped some defense would have been made here, for this was the hotbed of Secession & they wished to ruin us."
     We were forced to be submissive—humiliating as it was—for our little militia force—few arms &ccould have done nothing here—now that Lee’s & Johnston’s armies have surrendered. We have no further means of carrying on the war and could only have reaped desolation now at the last. Of course, "self-preservation" is the first instinct.
     Gen’l Brown seemed to be rather a hard—indifferent man. Said they were ordered to collect horses—arms & tithes of provisions as we did—from the commissary stores and they had soon robbed the place of all these things. Pa pointed out to him a building where were stored quantities of liquers of Mr. [Henry] Guardine of Charleston—wine merchant. At least $200,000 worth of splendid old wines—brandies &c considered invaluable by these men, but ought to have been destroyed—to prevent drunkenness and ruin here which was visited upon Columbia. He promised to keep his soldiers from it, but didn’t try. They were soon breaking in & drinking madly & all trembled for the effects. Happily—night soon came & then strict orders drove them out to camps in the suburbs. Only the patrol guards left to ride the streets & a guard—one or more at nearly every house. All was soon as quiet as though no hostile foe occupied the town & human hearts throbbed in terror.
     The soft young moon shone sweetly down on the fragrant earth & all was calm and lovely, but how the earth quaked with dread & horrible suspense in fear of worse things! Pa came safely home & we were all together. 
     The guard was a dirty, stupid youngster from mid Tenn., was wounded in Longstreet’s corps in Va., then deserted or was freed to go with the enemy. Has no choice either way I think, but wants to go back home. Seemed very contented to sit & walk around here & sleep. Yes, no plunder—though he needed a horse & clothes &c. He never left the place—walked around whistling or singing merrily (the native talent). Had a right good face. Talked with us all—too much if anything, but seemed earnest & took good care of us. Many villains asked if we had a guard—or came in & were repelled. So we were glad little "Hinton"* stayed so closely here with his "two story horse," which he promised to give us if he could get another—did not.
     The officer was a real cute & impertinent downEaster from New York—near the lakes. Red hair—florid face—hooked nose and nasal twang of the Yankees & their broad pronunciation. He tried to quiz us much, & Pa was rather too obsequious. I feared to speak to him—we would have quarreled &c. Got few replies from us & fewer smiles, though his were profuse, with many impertinent glances from cynical eyes. (He was a married man, he told Pa.) Rather gallant to us. Presumed once to ask me if I were single & guessed my age (26) exactly (Oh, the cute Yankee!) & urged me to guess his. At last I said 30 & he added three, but I felt disgusted!
     He told us they were Stoneman’s Com’d. Left Knoxville, Tenn., some weeks ago—many thousands strong dashed on through N.C. and here. Came from Caesar’s Head—the grand view in our state—marked it "their headquarters—April 30, 1865." Left there only yesterday at noon & rode rapidly here in a day—over 70 miles. The strongest brigade—Palmer’s going through Greenville. He couldn’t tell us their force—or their destination. Was guarded & suspectful of his words—not insulting, but prophesied that in two years Robt Lee, our southern hero whom they venerate, will be leading the Union armies to Mexico, to whip France &c. Will it be so, with our fickle, humiliated people? Perhaps so.

* I researched the 13th Tennessee Cavalry roster but could find no one named Hinton. There are several Heatons, Hiltons, and a Halton. There's also the possibility that Hinton was in the 9th Tennessee, whose roster I have not found. Gen. Longstreet (1821-1904), who was unfairly blamed for some of Robert E. Lee's failings, evidently had Hinton cousins. 


EMMALA'S WAR, Chapter 2➤ 'Many drunken demons'